Critics of the accusations against Basque parties argue that the focus on these incidents is a deliberate attempt to politicize sports for a broader nationalistic agenda. From this viewpoint, the narrative that PNV and EH Bildu are responsible for the harassment of fans is a simplification that ignores the complex social realities of the region. They contend that these incidents are often the work of fringe groups or individuals, not the result of an organized political campaign by regional parties.
Those holding this perspective suggest that the intense focus on these events by national-level politicians is intended to stir up controversy and undermine the legitimacy of Basque regionalism. By framing the issue as a conflict between 'Spanish fans' and 'Basque nationalists,' these critics argue that the debate is being used to distract from other pressing political issues and to polarize the public. They emphasize that the vast majority of the Basque population is peaceful and that the actions of a few should not be used to cast aspersions on the entire political establishment of the region.
Moreover, this view highlights that the political landscape in the Basque Country is evolving. Parties like EH Bildu have increasingly focused on institutional politics and social issues, distancing themselves from the confrontational tactics of the past. To suggest that they are orchestrating a campaign against football fans is seen as an outdated and inaccurate portrayal of their current political strategy. Instead of focusing on blame, this perspective calls for a more nuanced understanding of regional identity and a move away from using sports as a weapon in the ongoing territorial debate in Spain.