The recent invocation of the Manusmriti by Congress President Mallikarjun Kharge in the Rajya Sabha has sparked significant controversy. Opponents criticize the reference as inappropriate within the context of a modern constitutional democracy. They argue that the Manusmriti contains elements of discrimination that are incompatible with contemporary values of equality and justice.
The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) views such references as challenges to the supremacy of the Indian Constitution and the rule of law. They emphasize the importance of upholding constitutional principles over historical or religious texts that may propagate outdated social norms.
This incident highlights broader concerns about maintaining a secular and inclusive legislative discourse that respects the diversity of India's population. Critics contend that invoking texts like the Manusmriti in parliamentary debates risks deepening social divisions and undermining the progress made towards egalitarianism.
Overall, those opposing the invocation stress the need for parliamentary discussions to focus on constitutional values and modern principles, ensuring that governance aligns with democratic ideals and human rights.