Warning against Saifuddin's announcement, critics caution that stripping prison officers of immunity could have unintended consequences. They argue that frontline officers already face immense stress and danger, and without legal protection, they may become overly cautious or refrain from necessary interventions. This could jeopardize prison security and safety for both staff and inmates. Moreover, the decision opens officers to frivolous lawsuits, burdening the legal system and demoralizing the workforce. Some prison unions have called for a balanced approach, such as internal disciplinary mechanisms, rather than full exposure to prosecution. They fear the policy might lead to a staffing crisis as fewer people join the service.
News From Multiple Perspectives
Opposing Saifuddin's decision on prison officer immunity
Published July 28, 2026 at 8:32 AM UTC