Critics and some players have expressed concerns regarding the extreme 'burnt out' conditions currently present at Royal Birkdale. While links golf is traditionally defined by firm ground and unpredictable bounces, the current state of the course may push the limits of fairness. When the turf becomes excessively dry, the ball can behave in ways that are difficult to predict, potentially turning a test of skill into a game of chance where even well-struck shots are punished by unpredictable rolls.
This volatility raises questions about whether the course setup is overly punitive. If the ground is too firm, players may find it nearly impossible to hold greens, regardless of their accuracy. This can lead to frustration among the field and may diminish the quality of the competition if the outcome is determined more by luck—such as a ball taking an unfortunate bounce into a bunker—than by superior play. Maintaining a balance between a challenging setup and a fair playing surface is critical for a major championship.
Additionally, the focus on 'Open Experiences' and premium hospitality packages has drawn some skepticism from traditionalists. There is a concern that the commercialization of the event could overshadow the sporting element. As the focus shifts toward high-end spectator packages, there is a risk that the atmosphere of the tournament becomes more corporate, potentially alienating the core fan base that values the history and accessibility of golf's original championship.