The Home Ministry, under Amit Shah's guidance, argues that the FIRs filed against students involved in recent protests are part of standard legal procedures necessary to uphold public order and safety. The protests, while a form of democratic expression, at times escalated into activities perceived as disruptive or unlawful, requiring law enforcement intervention.
From this perspective, the government has a duty to ensure that demonstrations do not infringe on the rights of others or disturb daily life in the capital. Filing FIRs is a legal response to alleged violations rather than a targeted vendetta. Maintaining public security in a large and diverse democracy often involves balancing the right to protest with the rule of law.
Supporters of this approach believe that accusations of vendetta overlook the complexities of policing mass protests, especially when reports of property damage or violence emerge. They see the Home Ministry's actions as aligned with its responsibility to uphold law and order, not as political retribution.
Moving forward, emphasis on clear communication by law enforcement, fair investigation of complaints, and adherence to legal norms can help address public concerns while preserving the state's obligation to maintain peace and security during protests.