Critics of the current arrangement argue that Umno’s continued participation in the federal government comes at a significant cost to its identity and grassroots support. By aligning with Pakatan Harapan, the party risks alienating its traditional base, who may view the partnership as a betrayal of the party's core principles. Skeptics, including figures like Puad Zarkashi, suggest that the party’s leadership is overly focused on retaining ministerial positions, which may be blinding them to the long-term erosion of the party's political relevance and influence.
There is a growing concern that this compromise limits Umno’s ability to act as a strong, independent voice for its supporters. When the party is tied to the decisions and policies of a coalition government, it often finds itself unable to criticize or oppose actions that may be unpopular among its members. This lack of autonomy can lead to a sense of disillusionment among the rank and file, who may feel that the party has sacrificed its values for the sake of executive power.
Furthermore, the internal debate highlights a deeper issue regarding the party's future direction. Critics argue that instead of clinging to government positions, Umno should focus on rebuilding its strength and credibility as a distinct political force. They warn that by failing to address these concerns, the party risks further decline in future elections, as voters may turn to alternatives that offer a more clear and uncompromising political vision. The focus on cabinet posts, they contend, is a short-sighted strategy that ignores the fundamental need for internal reform and ideological clarity.